Cincinnati sits on heavy clay soil that holds water against foundation walls instead of draining it, building hydrostatic pressure that pushes water through the cove joint, cracks, and floor. A high seasonal water table in the valleys and freeze-thaw cycling make it worse.
More detail
The dominant cause is the soil. Greater Cincinnati sits on heavy lacustrine and glacial-till clay, which has very low permeability. Instead of letting rainwater drain away from the foundation, clay holds water against the wall and swells as it absorbs, generating hydrostatic pressure that pushes water through any path in the foundation: the cove joint where floor meets wall, hairline wall cracks, block cores, stone-mortar joints, and porous concrete itself. After a multi-day Cincinnati soaker the water table in many neighborhoods rises high enough to put the footer underwater, which is exactly when basements take on water. Geography compounds it. The Mill Creek valley and the Ohio River bottoms keep the seasonal water table high in lower-lying parts of Northside, Lower Price Hill, Sayler Park, and the Kentucky river towns. Hillside lots in Mt. Adams, Mt. Lookout, Columbia Tusculum, and the Hyde Park slopes get lateral water sheeting downhill into the uphill wall. Freeze-thaw cycling through a Cincinnati winter opens and widens cracks on a multi-year timeline, creating fresh entry paths. And the region has a huge stock of pre-1940 stone-and-block foundations (Northside, Price Hill, Clifton, Camp Washington, Covington, Newport) that were never built to be waterproof by modern standards. Finally, the older combined sewer neighborhoods can see the public sewer surcharge during heavy rain and back water up through floor drains, which is a different problem than groundwater seepage and is addressed through MSDGC backwater-valve programs. The on-site assessment identifies which of these mechanisms is driving your specific leak before any solution is quoted.